When my wife saw it, she cried because it was so beautiful.

A Noguchi pendant light is suspended beside the two-story tall stone and plaster fireplace.

The fireplace runs all the way to the ceiling, which features reclaimed beamed supports.

Image may contain Chair Furniture Window Table Dining Table Desk Indoors Interior Design Architecture and Building

Sourced from Marshall Farm Woodworworks on Chappaquiddick Island, the dining table is paired with Monk chairs by Carlo Scarpa and sits beneath an antique candelabra. The window-walled room gives diners the feeling of being outside on the property’s oak grove.

(Ariel explains that it will weather to a gray to match the Marthas Vineyard vernacular.)

Behind the living room sits the kitchen.

Twin pendants by Rose Uniacke hover above the island which is painted blacknow a signature of the family.

Image may contain Fireplace Indoors Interior Design Hearth Chair and Furniture

A Noguchi pendant light is suspended beside the two-story tall stone and plaster fireplace. Antique finds surround the hearth, including firetools from RT Facts in Kent, Connecticut and coil baskets from the local Chilmark Flea Market.

Outside, a combination of paned glass and picture windows add a layered look to the barn-like home.

The house is surrounded by farms and farmland, it needed to relate to that.

Humor lives there, adds Ariel.

Image may contain Wood Plywood Architecture Building House Housing Indoors Loft Room and Vault Ceiling

The fireplace runs all the way to the ceiling, which features reclaimed beamed supports.

A view from the pantry to the entryway and a tiny radish painting by Antonello Radi from Il Buco.

Splatterware dishes from March SF are stacked in the shelves.

A limewash treatment on the overmantle in moody gray adds sophistication to the focus point.

Image may contain Book Publication Indoors Interior Design Lamp Couch Furniture Coffee Table Table and Architecture

In the living room, a custom sofa, custom coffee table by Robert Pluhowski, and a chair from Ashe Leandro’s furniture line, Ruemmler no 612, orients guests toward conversation around the hearth.

A baroque walnut cabinet from Cafiero Select stands tall as the familys favorite piece.

The secretary style cabines is now a bar stocked with Gucci stirrup cups Alexi collected.

Their New York kitchen kicked off a black kitchen trend, in my opinion, says Ariel.

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Kitchen Architecture Building Dining Room Dining Table Furniture and Room

Behind the living room sits the kitchen. Twin pendants by Rose Uniacke hover above the island which is painted black—now a signature of the family.

For the real thing, a covered porch is populated with furniture for outdoor summertime living.

Patterns play in the guest room with a vintage Moroccan rag rug and bed throw by Jeanette Farrier.

Upstairs, arched doorways lead to bedrooms where subtle nautical touches abound.

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Lamp Furniture Floor Box Room and WalkIn Closet

A view from the pantry to the entryway and a tiny radish painting by Antonello Radi from Il Buco. Splatterware dishes from March SF are stacked in the shelves.

In true Marthas Vineyard fashion, this home is filled with aged designs.

An unfinished 17th-century Portuguese silk tapestry draws the eye in the primary bedroom.

Custom his and hers vanities flank the Agape Ottocento bathtub.

Image may contain Architecture Building Dining Room Dining Table Furniture Indoors Room Table Chair and Floor

The breakfast room, furnished with a reclaimed pine table by Rob Pluhoski, antique Gustavian dining chairs, and a light by Carlo Scarpa, offers a prime vista of the Eben Armer-designed fireplace.

I sent it to my sister, and she just said, What?

I was like, Just say yes!

And we bought it and its everyones favorite piece.

Image may contain Cabinet Furniture Sideboard Closet Cupboard Wood and Person

A baroque walnut cabinet from Cafiero Select stands tall as the family’s favorite piece.

Another benefit of decorating for your family?

Not having tofullylet go of some of your long-held antiques.

A sconce Ariel found in a Parisian flea market has made its way into the powder room.

Image may contain Cabinet Furniture Closet Cupboard Sideboard Wood Adult Person Wedding and Indoors

The secretary style cabines is now a bar stocked with Gucci stirrup cups Alexi collected.

Scrolls feature throughout the home as a nautical motif.

A colorful view of a guest bedroom.

Theres so much cooking happening all the timeand cocktails.

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Architecture Building House Housing Porch Desk Furniture Table and Lamp

Michael Trapp’s iron chairs add a punch of red to the outdoor living spaces furnished with a table from Montage Antiques and daybeds from Janus et Cie.

Its full of life, says Ariel.

As for whether or not Seth was able to abide by his wifes original wish?

Sheep in the boys bedroom pays homage to the real-life sheep at a nearby farm.

Image may contain Grass Plant Lawn Backyard Nature Outdoors Yard Architecture Building House Housing and Villa

Oak trees and boulders unearthed from the property fill the lawn of the cedar planked house.

A miniature oyster painting by the entryway.

Image may contain Home Decor Lamp Chair Furniture Art Painting Rug Indoors Interior Design Corner and Bed

Patterns play in the guest room with a vintage Moroccan rag rug and bed throw by Jeanette Farrier.

Image may contain Book Publication Chair Furniture Desk Table Indoors Interior Design Window Person and Lamp

A 1970s monkey rattan lamp sits atop a Zijlstra Meubelen desk in walnut and brass that Seth uses as his Podcast HQ in the summers.

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Chair Furniture Lamp Home Decor Bed Desk Table Rug Bench and Window

In the primary bedroom, a Navajo rug purchased by Seth for Alexi as a gift sits by the window bench.

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Bed Furniture Home Decor Lamp Person Bedroom Room Bench and Wood Panels

An unfinished 17th-century Portuguese silk tapestry draws the eye in the primary bedroom.

Image may contain Floor Flooring Indoors Interior Design Bathing Bathtub Person Tub Arch Architecture and Sink

Custom his and hers vanities flank the Agape Ottocento bathtub.

Image may contain Wood Hardwood and Bronze

Scrolls feature throughout the home as a nautical motif.

Image may contain Home Decor Rug Cushion Quilt Pillow and Person

A colorful view of a guest bedroom.

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Home Decor Rug Floor Art Painting Bed Furniture and Flooring

Sheep in the boys’ bedroom pays homage to the real-life sheep at a nearby farm.

Image may contain Lamp Art Painting and Lampshade

A miniature oyster painting by the entryway.